Music Improvisation and Creation
Human and Computational
May 31 – June 3, 2021
Ascea, Italy
~call for papers~
These two terms,
‘improvise’ and ‘create’, are in frequent use, not only in several, but in many
disparate ways and their nature, analysis and description currently come to a
head by the efforts to translate them into Artificial Intelligence (AI). So
first, in order to decide if all – and in particular these – human capacities
are computable, one has to get beyond the notoriously vague conceptions and
cavalier uses of them. How are they distinguished from inventions,
inspirations, impulses, experiments, accidents, discoveries, etc.? What are the
criteria for their descriptive or their occasional uses? Are they co-extensive,
inter-dependent, conceptually distinguishable? Is creation always or generally
the product of improvisation? Is improvisation dependent on a learning process
that may or may not lead to a creative product? Is it consistent and/or useful
to (attempt to) define creativity (e.g. [4])?
Several projects
are underway to install these capacities in (students as well as in) machines
(e.g. [3]); since the success of some of these (particularly in music), we need
to ask how human and machine improvisations relate, and whether they do. Are
improvisation and creation teachable? Are they temporary or permanent
capacities? Can one acquire talent? Can a machine be(come) talented? Can
machines improvise in the sense that humans do, can they co-improvise, and is
there a valid general approach to understanding or evaluating machine
improvisation (e.g. [1])?
In what way does
it make sense to describe or analyse the activity of improvisation? Can
improvisation be reduced to parameters? [2] Is improvisation a general or
particular category of action or performance? (We could here invite critique of
Ryle’s “Improvisation” [5].) Is musical improvisation a particular kind? Can a
computational improviser system trained in music then be applied to improvise
in other kinds of activities such as decision-making in (all?) other AI
programs? This call is for fresh and detailed examinations of the logic of the
concepts of ‘improvisation’ and ‘creation’.
The XIth International Wassard Elea Symposium,
held in Ascea, Southern Italy, invites musicologists, computer
scientists, philosophers and other academics to submit papers on the topics of
this year’s theme. Sessions of 90 min. include speaker, commentator and open
discussion (40/20/30). Participants whose papers are accepted are expected to
also prepare a commentary on another presentation at the meeting. All suitable
contributions are published in our journal, Wassard
Elea Rivista.
Inquiries are very welcome. Full papers (attached in Word format) should be sent directly to the
organizers:
Dr. René Mogensen,
Birmingham City University, United Kingdom: Rene.Mogensen@bcu.ac.uk,
or
Prof. Lars
Aagaard-Mogensen, Italy: wassardelea@gmail.com.
→
Deadline for submissions: February 15, 2021.
There is no
registration fee; participants will receive details about accommodation rates
in due course.
Wassard Elea
Refugium for writers, artists, composers, and scholars
in Southern Italy
Wassardelea.blogspot.it
Selected references:
[1] Agres, K., Forth, J., Wiggins, G. A.: “Evaluation
of Musical Creativity and Musical Metacreation Systems”. Computers in Entertainment vol. 14(3), pp. 3:1 – 3:33 (2016)
[2] Biasutti, M., Frezza, L.: “Dimensions of Music
Improvisation”. Creativity Research
Journal vol. 21(2), pp. 232–242 (2009)
[3] Gifford, T., Knotts, S., McCormack, J., Kalonaris,
S., Yee-King, M., d’Inverno, M.: “Computational Systems for Music
Improvisation”. Digital Creativity
vol. 29(1), pp. 19–36 (2018) & Abraham, A.: “The Promises and Perils of the
Neuroscience of Creativity”, Frontiers in
Human Neuroscience vol 7, article 246, pp. 1-9 (2013)
- Gouveia, S.
S. The Age of Artificial Intelligence: An
Exploration. Vernon Press, Wilmington & Malaga (2020)
[4] Runco, M. A., Jaeger, G. J.: “The Standard
Definition of Creativity”. Creativity
Research Journal vol. 24(1), pp. 92–96 (2012) & de Sousa, F. C.: “Still
the Elusive Definition of Creativity”, International
Journal of Psychology: a Biopsychosocial Approach vol 2, pp. 55-82 (2008)
[5] Ryle, G.: “Improvisation”. Mind vol. 85 (337), pp. 69–83 (1976)